Intel P4 Extreme Edition

We reviewed the P4 3.2 GHz processor last August (page 117) and said it was

probably the last of the Pentium 4 series. But now, Intel has come up with a

special edition of the same processor called the P4 3.2 GHz EE (Extreme

Edition). It has the same clock and system bus frequency as the previous

processor, but has got an additional 2 MB level 3 cache. More cache means the

processor will fetch more data from the high-speed cache instead of the slower

system memory,  resulting in better performance. 

The processor is ideal for complex computing requirements such as, vector and

matrix multiplications; statistical and geometrical modeling; and simulation and

encryption. So this time , we used a different set of benchmarks that involved

computational modeling, molecular dynamics and encryption. There were three

benchmarks from Sciencemark called Molecular Dynamics, Primordia, which test the

processor for molecular simulation, and Cipher, which runs the 128-bit AES

algorithm. We also used Rightmark, which does computational modeling of physical

processes and solves complex 3D graphics problems. Plus, we also ran two regular

benchmarks, Content Creation Winstone 2001(CCW), which runs real world high-end

multimedia applications, and the Quake III Arena game demos. Lastly, we did a

Linux kernel compilation using the Fedora Core 1 distribution and measured the

time taken to complete. The hardware used was an Intel 865GBF motherboard with

512 MB dual channel DDR-400 and GeForce 4600 Ti graphics card having 128 MB

dedicated graphics memory. We compared it against a regular 3.2 GHz P4.

Starting with CCW, the extreme edition scored 106.7 compared to 100.6 of the

regular processor, ie 6% improvement, which is significant for a benchmark that

doesn’t solely depend on raw CPU power, but also takes into account other

system components. Quake III Arena is famous for its CPU testing powers and also

scales very well as processor specifications improve. The regular processor

managed 390 fps, while the extreme edition scored 488 fps, a whopping 25%

increase. There were improvements in the remaining benchmarks as well, (shown in

the results table). Finally coming to Linux kernel compilation, the regular 3.2

GHz took 3 mins and 44 secs to complete a ‘#make bzImage’ command, while the

Extreme Edition took only 2 mins and 53 secs, saving about 51 secs.

To summarize, the new P4 3.2 GHz Extreme Edition brings a lot of power,

useful for computing intensive applications.If you have such a requirement and

are willing to pay the premium, it’s a good choice.

Anoop Mangla