The initial high cost of a P4 processor and RDRAM meant that systems based on this processor were out of reach of most users. However, the recent cut in P4 prices has made them more affordable. To facilitate this penetration, Intel recently introduced its 845 chipset (Brookdale), which supports regular SDRAM instead of RDRAM, reducing the price further.
|
We checked out the Transcend TS-ABD4 motherboard, which is based on the i845 chipset. Like most P4 boards, this one too needs a special power supply, so you can’t put to use your older ATX cabinets. The motherboard has a socket 478, which can house the smaller P4 processors with the new mPGA packaging. Its three DIMM slots support up to 3 GB, 133 MHz SDRAM. Expandability is not an issue with five PCI slots and a CNR (Communication and Networking Riser) slot.
Sound is onboard, and there’s an AGP Pro slot, which can take in the latest graphics cards. Laid out on an ATX form-factor all connectors and ports are onboard and well labeled for easy identification. The board is completely jumperless, making its configuration even easier.
We tested it with a P4 2 GHz processor, 128 MB SDRAM, an Asus V7700 GeForce 2 display card, Barracuda ATA III hard drive, and Windows 98 SE, and compared its performance with a similar board from Mercury, the 845 KOB WFSX. The difference between the two was that the Mercury had the older socket 423, which housed the earlier P4 processors. To put things into perspective we also added the results of an 850-chipset-based board from DFI, model WT70-EC, which used the same configuration except for its 128 MB
RDRAM.
We tested all boards for graphics and gaming using 3D Mark 2001, 3D Winbench 2000 for graphics intensive games, Quake III Arena as always to test the gaming capabilities, and Business and Content Creation Winstone 2001 for regular productivity and high-end apps. A look at the results table shows clearly that there is very little to choose from when it comes to performance. Another point to keep in mind is that these small differences in scores will hardly translate into anything for the end user. So the deciding factor will have to be the features offered by the boards and their respective prices.
At Rs 7,600, the Transcend is a good deal as it performs well, has a useful set of features, and most importantly it works with conventional and cheaper
SDRAM.
3DMark 2001 |
3DWinbench 2000 FPS |
Quake III FPS |
Business Winstone 2001 Winstone Units |
Content Creation Wistone 2001 (Winmarks) Winstone Unit |
|
DFI- WT70-EC | 3426 | 122 | 157 | 44.5 | 43.1 |
Transcend TS-ABD4 | 3303 | 118 | 131 | 40.8 | 39.4 |
Mercury-845 KOB WFSX | 2886 | 117 | 128 | 43.5 | 42.7 |
Sachin Makhija at PCQ Labs